The research report was launched by Alzheimer’s Pakistan in a Research dissemination seminar organised on April 20, 2018 at Faletti’s Hotel, Lahore. The Seminar started with the recitation of Holy Quran. Prof. Dr. Yasmin Raashid, patron, Alzheimer’s Pakistan welcomed the participants and provided an overview of Dementia, its symptoms, diagnosis, treatment and prognosis. She presented the global and national incidence of the disease and highlighted the Alzheimer’s care services provided by Alzheimer’s Pakistan. Dr. Yasmin said that the number of people with dementia are increasing in Pakistan due to the increased life expectancy and it is time that all the stake holders including the government, medical professions, NGOs and the community join hands and provided the much needed dementia care services in the country.
Principal Investigator Professor Asghar Zaidi, of the University of Southampton provided the results of the research. He said that “Dementia is a global health priority, but progress towards its understanding and treatment in low and middle-income countries has been slow, despite rapidly ageing populations. We hope our report will inform policymakers in Pakistan and across South Asia – helping to improve the lives of people with the disease and their caregivers.” Working in collaboration with Brighton and Sussex Medical School, The AGA Khan University and the charities Age International, HANDS and Alzheimer’s Pakistan, the researchers conducted a series of interviews with people living with dementia and their caregivers, and focus groups with members of the general public. They also carried out semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders, such as practitioners and policymakers.
One of the most striking findings in the report is the lack of awareness of dementia and its symptoms. Respondents attributed the disease to a range of factors, such as getting old, doing too much, stress, shock, social isolation and in more extreme cases, black magic. These misconceptions led to misunderstandings about care and prognosis. Perhaps most concerning is a strong stigma associated with the disease, or generally with any other mental health problems.
An important finding is that persons with dementia mentioned their loss of sense of time of day and how this impacts on their ability to know when to pray. Timing of daily prayers is very important in Islam and this symptom can be quite challenging for Muslim patients and their family caregivers. In addition, a loss of sense of orientation can make it difficult to lay prayer mats correctly. The religiosity in Pakistan’s culture places great emphasis on praying and closeness to God as one gets older. This means it can be difficult for people with dementia to meet these societal expectations.
Some caregivers spoke of feeling isolated, with more women than men also expressing concern about how other duties had been affected, such as child caring, household tasks and their paid jobs. They also spoke of effects on their own health and feelings of frustration and guilt. Many different reasons were given for why people with dementia and caregivers didn’t access extra support, including cost, transport and paid care not being as good as family care, and most people said they were unaware of any external help or public services available to them.
The report authors highlight a number of important policy implications stemming from their research. Key recommendations include:
- Developing a national campaign in Pakistan to raise awareness of dementia, highlighting symptoms and their progression, and how to seek help.
- More funding for affordable and accessible specialist dementia services, such as day care centres, dedicated hospital wards, staff and support groups.
- The authors recommend a focus on help in the home, as families in Pakistan are more likely to accept home based care.
- Communication from religious leaders about dementia, both in terms of awareness raising and the acceptability to seek help and exemption from religious duties.
- A greater emphasis on research and evidence informed policymaking, with knowledge transfer from research carried out in different regions of the world, taking into account cultural sensitivities.
Speaking at this occasion, the Co-Investigator, Dr. Hussain Jafri, Secretary General, Alzheimer’s Pakistan said that this research on “Understanding, Beliefs and Treatment of Dementia in Pakistan” is the first ever international psychosocial research on Dementia in Pakistan and has been conducted to identify peoples’ beliefs and attitudes towards dementia and develop the best policies to help those living with the disease in the country. The research report provides concrete recommendations on what all needs improvement to bring about a positive change in the lives of the people with dementia and their families.
After this, a panel discussion was held, which was conducted by Dr. Hussain Jafri. This high level panel consisted of the following distinguished panellist:
- Dr. Ashraf Nizami, President, Pakistan Medical Association
- Dr. Nosheen Hamid, Member Punjab Assembly
- Dr. Ruhi Khalid, Head of Psychology Department, BNU
- Mr. Amir Malik, The News
- Prof. Dr. Anjum Bashir, Head of Psychiatry, Central Park Medical College, Lahore
- Dr. Amjad Tufail, Dementia Family Caregiver
The panellists highly appreciated this collaborative research as it not only provided valuable findings but also provided a number of important policy implications, which could go a long way in developing Dementia care services in the country. The panellists also highlighted specific issues related to their fields of expertise arising from the research and provided expert opinion.
The Chief Guest of the Seminar was Lord Dr Shaukat Nawaz Khan, UK. Speaking at the occasion, Lord Shaukat appreciated the collaborative research on Dementia in Pakistan between the UK and Pakistani researchers. He said that there is a need to expand the scope of future researches to the rural areas as well so that a more comprehensive assessment of the issues at the national level could be taken.
Zia Haider Rizvi, president, Alzheimer’s Pakistan presented the vote of thanks, after which shields were presented to the speakers, panellists, distinguished guests and the Chief Guest.
The report, Understanding, Beliefs and Treatment of Dementia in Pakistan: Interim Findings can be accessed at Alzheimer’s Pakistan websitehttp://alz.org.pk/Understanding%20challenges%20of%20dementi…